HiFX problems, delays transferring money

Currency exchange Spain
Post reply   Start new thread
:: New - Old :: Old - New

Pages: Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 |

Forum home :: Latest threads :: Search forums
The Comments
16 Apr 2007 8:29 PM by KevinGames Star rating. 17 posts Send private message

 

I'm quite worried about some of people's experiences of money transfers.  Does anyone know the best method to transfer large amount of funds from Euro to Stirling.  I'm hoping to complete on the sale of my property in Spain.  I am a non resident.  Someone has mentioned to me to have a Euro draft but I was considering using a broker to transfer back from Spain to England.  I have used Currencies Direct in the past for bank transfers, Stirling to Euros in order to pay my mortgage.  I'd be grateful for any advice.  I know generally people on this forum would be transferring funds the other way around but I'm looking for the best rate/method.

Thanks in advance.




Like 0      
16 Apr 2007 9:53 PM by Smiley Star rating in San Pedro de Alcanta.... 2502 posts Send private message

Smiley´s avatar
If you have an account with CD there should be nothing to stop you transferring the other way. Otherwise check with your local bank in the UK about encashment of a Euro bankers draft - there will invariably be a charge but I am sure there used to be a system to facilitate this

_______________________

Smiley - patrick@marbellamortgages.com  www.marbellamortgages.com   www.comparetravelcash.co.uk




Like 0      
11 Sep 2007 11:47 AM by mikeandcarol Star rating. 4 posts Send private message

Two issues from this string...

1) I too frequently use HIFX and I am very satisfied with the servcie that they offer.

2) I am concerned that there may have been a breach of the Data Protection Act, which is quite disconcerting.

 

Mike, Stoke on Trent





Like 0      
27 Jun 2008 11:58 AM by Nquire Star rating. 2 posts Send private message

Dear Kevin

Can you please contact me re your troubles with HIFX. My husband is presently having serious problems with them. They are refusing to acknowledge our complaints and have been extremely aggressive in their dealings. They are demanding a payment we do not owe and enforcing court action.
I have found evidence that this is happening to other people but because they are such a large firm they can pressurise people individually into paying up. It is about time they were exposed but it is difficult to do  this as a one off. It might be helpful if we were in contact with each other.
There is an article on the internet by another client 
whereby HIFX charged a client for selling back to the market.

It is a very similar experience to ours and we have no proof of purchase or sale. I believe they must make a lot of money through such dealings as well as the type of deal they did with you.
If you can help please get in touch.
Regards
Beryl



Like 0      
27 Jun 2008 11:30 PM by andenca Star rating in London. 44 posts Send private message

Hi, just in case this help anyone, we have used Moneycorp in the past with no problems and better exchange rates than HIFX.





Like 0      
28 Jun 2008 10:27 AM by Nquire Star rating. 2 posts Send private message

Am still trying to contact Kevinm it is not the rates I am concerned about it is the manner in which they operate and the fact that when they make mistakes they refuse to accept them and expect the client to pay.
If any one knows Kevin m please would you ask him to contact me.
Thanks



Like 0      
28 Jun 2008 12:22 PM by sterling Star rating in Kent & Partaloa, Alm.... 206 posts Send private message

We use  worldwide currencies have done for a few years now, excellent service, can now transfer on the internet now as well. Good rates as well. Never had any trouble.



_______________________
Sterling



Like 0      
11 Jul 2008 12:17 PM by kevinm Star rating in Somewhere so nice, i.... 26 posts Send private message


Names editted out to comply with forum rules. The firm we used are referred to as "my company."

Money transfer companies provide a service. If you are in the UK when you enter a contract with them (i.e. request that they transfer money for you) then they are subject to UK law in the provision of that service. Equally, you are bound by the terms and conditions of the contract (provided the terms are reasonable, but that is a different matter!) The law states that the service must be provided by a competent person (or persons) in the organisation, and that they must use reasonable care and skill. In my case, I was advised verbally when to transmit funds to my company so that it could then forward them to Spain in time to complete the purchase of my property. I took that advice without checking my company’s small print – perhaps a mistake on my part, but I thought these were the guys at the sharp end and they would know what they are talking about. So, I transferred my money to my company and off we go to Spain to complete the purchase of our house. On the day that completion was due, that the Spanish bank had not received the funds. During several frantic telephone calls made by both my lawyer and myself (outside the Notary’s office!) my company admitted that they had received the funds from me several days beforehand, but that they had failed to forward them to the Spanish bank. They said new computer system was to blame, and that it was my company’s fault. We returned to the UK having breached our contract on the purchase. We had the additional costs associated with appointing a power of attorney and, obviously, we were unable to obtain the keys to our new property to measure up and order furniture (we bought unfurnished). Hence we had to make an additional trip to Spain to do this, for which I hold my company responsible. The other unfortunate thing is that we were unable to use our new home for the Christmas period.

 

After our return to the UK, during a phone call to my company, they confirmed that they were at fault, compensation would be paid to us (although no figure was mentioned) and I was told to confirm my complaint in writing. This I did, but things went downhill from there. I received a letter from [name removed] of my company’s “Compliance Department.” This stated that, following a “thorough investigation” my company had acted without fault and blamed me for the late transmission of my funds to them. They claimed they had not received the funds from me until after the completion date, contradicting what they had said – and repeated – several times earlier. They then quoted from their small print, which states a ridiculous length of time to allow funds to reach the destination. (I was subsequently advised that this is to cover 3rd world countries, where the banking systems are slow (or any country where the banks do not use the Banks Automated Clearing System or BACS). However, Europe is pretty quick – all European countries use BACS). My solicitor told me that they acted incorrectly by giving me the advice that they did and then by “hiding behind the details in the small print.”

 

As you will know, all conversations with my company are recorded. I wrote to them and requested copies of all the telephone conversations that we had had. They sent a CD with a total of 16 minutes and 9 seconds’ worth of conversations. I contacted my mobile phone operator for statements and totalled the calls to my company – this showed a further 49 minutes and 38seconds, and my home phone bill showed a further 35 minutes and 49 seconds. (This does not include the call made by my lawyer.) I asked for the missing conversations to be sent – I didn’t receive them. I sought legal advice.

 

You may or may not know is that my company - like others - records conversations and stores them digitally, i.e. on computers, so they are subject to the Data Protection Act. You are entitled to copies of all the personal data that a company holds on you. The procedure to obtain them is to write to the Head of Compliance – [name removed], I was told at the time – and make a formal request for copies of the information (in this case, telephone conversations) under Section 7(1) of the Data Protection Act 1998. See http://www.ico.gov.uk/ for more information – there is even a sample letter on the site telling you how to ask for this information. Send your letter by recorded delivery and enclose the fee (£10 at the time, see the ICO website for confirmation of this). I did this – I received a letter from [name removed], Compliance Manager, saying that they would send the information on CD to my solicitors. They even returned my cheque, saying that my company does not charge a fee for the service. That was the last I heard from them – September 2007. The conversations would have clearly shown that I had followed their instructions to the letter, and would also have confirmed their admission of fault. Their failure to send this information contravenes the Data Protection Act for which my company can be reported to the Information Commissioner’s Office. Unfortunately, this organisation will do nothing for an individual, making it little more than a toothless watchdog, but confirmation from them that the law has been breached will assist any court case you subsequently pursue.

 

I have not done anything since receiving that last letter as, in the space of a year, both my parents died and we moved house three times. However your posting has prompted me to take further action (if it’s not too late).

 

BTW you may feel that my company was not really to blame in my case, as their new computer system had failed to notify them that the funds I sent to the my company account had arrived. However, the IT department has the same requirement to provide their services to the rest of the company with the same reasonable skill and care. That’s still true if the work is contracted out (I am a systems support specialist, so I know this to be the case). So the buck stops with my company, whatever they may say.


I apologise for the delay in sending this. I typed the bulk of it a couple of days ago but I have only just completed it.




This message was last edited by kevinm on 7/13/2008.

This message was last edited by kevinm on 7/13/2008.

This message was last edited by kevinm on 7/13/2008.



Like 0      
25 Sep 2008 6:36 PM by kevinm Star rating in Somewhere so nice, i.... 26 posts Send private message

With my apologies for the delay in replying, here is why I'm not doing anything. My solicitor emailed the following:

"Dear Kevin

 

I hope that the weather is better in Spain than it is here because it has certainly been diabolical. 

 

Referring to your query with Alison whilst I was on holiday, I apologise for only just coming back to you but I am only now getting on top of the backlog created by going away, to the point where it makes you wonder if it is worth going.

 

I assume that the company you are upset about is an English company.  If it is a Spanish company then Spanish law will apply and I would not be in a position to advise.  On the assumption it is an English company that was supposed to be sending money over, I still think that you have an uphill task if you try to pursue it.  The reason I say that is, the amount involved, i.e. £1,000 mentioned to me, under English law would represent a small claim.  The Courts have set a rule that anything under £5,000, no matter how complicated, is classed as a small claim.  The assumption is, therefore, that members of the public can sort their own legal affairs out without recourse to lawyers.  If you do have recourse to lawyers and a claim under £5,000, then even if you are successful, you are unlikely to get back anything other than your Court fee and a very small amount of fixed legal costs.  The reality is, therefore, that if it costs £2,000 or £3,000 or more to pursue a claim, you are only likely to get back a few hundred pounds at the very best in terms of Court fee and costs.  In practical terms, it makes pursuing small claims virtually a commercial waste of time.  I personally think this has been done deliberately to try to discourage small claims because the reality is that quite often what are claims that are classed as small claims are quite legally complex and quite how a member of the public would be expected to deal with them beats me but, unfortunately, we don’t make the rules.

 

You would have to show that the company were negligent in not getting money to you on time.  You mention small print and I assume that there is an agreement between you and the company to transmit the money.  Often, there will be exemption clauses in the small print which exempt them from liability if there are breakdowns out of their control.  This is quite standard practice.  Without seeing any agreement between you, it is difficult to be precise but I have tried to set out the principles.

 

What you would need to do is to write them a formal letter before action, setting out what you are claiming and why and giving them a reasonable period of time to respond.  If ultimately nothing comes of it, you would then be expected to issue a summons in the County Court claiming the £1,000.  This is really where the cost aspect comes in because once you have issued a summons, you have embarked upon a course of action which it is not always possible to just simply pull out of.

 

If they choose to defend it and start to claim exemptions and small print, then obviously it is up to you to prove that legally they are in the wrong and, again, that is where the cost comes in.  I will happily look at the agreement between you if you want but that has to be the starting point because if they are going to claim exemptions, then they will do it under that agreement.  If it is unclear that they had the benefit of any exemptions or get out clauses, then the letter before action could be sent.  I will leave it entirely up to you but I would certainly hesitate to advise you to throw what could be a considerable amount of legal costs at it in the sure and certain knowledge that even if you succeed, you are not going to get back anything like what it has cost you to make the claim.

 

I look forward to hearing from you."

 

I have, however, heard from the Information Commissioner's Office and they have asked me to complete a form for a "potential breach of the Data Protection Act." They are little more than a toothless watchdog, powerless to apprehend, never mind impose any fines! Money transfers are outside the control of the FSA, too, as you will have read above.

So - we lost our money, and [company name not quoted, in accordance with posting rules] got away with it - again.



Like 0      
29 Oct 2008 3:06 PM by D-Brain Star rating. 1 posts Send private message

I've used the same broker in the past, but now use a company called First Rate FX. I found that First Rate offered better rates of exchange and they bent over backwards to help me with any problems that I had, even if they were not currency related!! They might be worth a try in the future...



Like 0      
17 Nov 2008 8:35 AM by bella750 Star rating. 19 posts Send private message

Hi,

 

Just to let you know I have been using a company called Global currencies direct based in Playa Flamenca.  They have been brilliant.  The girl I have dealt with is Michelle.  They can freeze a rate for you for up to a year and you only need to pay 10%.  This is excellent at the moment if you are taking money back to the UK as the rate was an awful1.13 on Friday. If you want any contact details PM me and Ill find them out for you





Like 0      
24 Feb 2010 12:41 PM by whufc48 Star rating. 4 posts Send private message

Now that currency specialists are becoming FSA regulated, it is always encouraged to go for the ones that are.

I work for the comparison site SendMoneyHome.org and we list foreign exchange brokers that are fully regulated and hold client funds in segregated accounts.

It is also an effective site to find the best deals - if I could provide 1 tip - Don't let the banks cash in!





Like 0      
28 Jul 2010 1:09 PM by hifx scam Star rating. 2 posts Send private message

What was the point of this guy from HiFX posting a PR exercise message here when he doesn't even have the front to resolve the issue publicly? He has seriously dented any credibility he and his dodgy organisation may have had by ignoring a customers valid complaint. This is exactly the kind of company that pays lip service to "great customer service" but never back it up.

I have heard quite a few scare stories about HiFX severely delaying peoples funds (maybe they want to make an extra few days interest out of all of our hard-earned money). I for one would never trust them with sending my money again...





Like 0      
20 May 2011 5:59 PM by johnperez Star rating. 3 posts Send private message

I was thinking of using them! Hmm dunno now!? :/

 





Like 0      
20 May 2011 6:20 PM by Tolly99 Star rating. 19 posts Send private message

I use them regularly and have never had any problems  - that is not to say, that the odd delay won't occur, but in my experience with them it takes 3 working days from leaving my GBP account to arriving in my Euro account , and i get updates via email / text to let you know the status of the transaction





Like 0      
20 May 2011 6:31 PM by mgk Star rating in Penthouse 2. 241 posts Send private message

mgk´s avatar

 Always use Smart Currency exchange --- never had a problem!



_______________________

www.condadoelectricalservices.com        condadoes@live.co.uk

tel.605 832  795




Like 0      

Pages: Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 |

Post reply    Start new thread


Previous Threads

New messages on El Rincon Costa Blanca Development Forum - 0 posts
Have you visited Malaga yet? - 4 posts
spanish bank charges - 24 posts
Telefonica & Broadband - 7 posts
NEW LOW COST AIRLINE TO ALMERIA - 20 posts
Sorry another question - 0 posts
Pets in apartments - 5 posts
HELP NEEDED URGENTLY - 20 posts
Making a Will - 3 posts
Property owners at Roda - 4 posts
La Recoleta - 2 posts
FibbyUk's document - Paying taxes in Spain (Non Residents) - 18 posts
Merry Christmas Everyone!!! - 11 posts
amputees in coata blanca, north - 0 posts
Agents for rentals - 1 posts
Merry Christmas & a Happy New Year - 0 posts
Working from home in Spain - 4 posts
Corruption - 2 posts
property in Tenerife - 0 posts
What happened to the OTHER thread ? i thought there were TWO on here before ! - 0 posts
Artificial Grass - Good Idea or not? - 0 posts
Spanish builders - 2 posts
Fuente Aloha, Nueva Andelucia - 5 posts
Condes de Iza - 0 posts
Iznajar - Cordoba - 5 posts

Number of posts in this thread: 56

DISCLAIMER:  All opinions posted on these message boards are the opinion solely of the poster and do not necessarily reflect the opinion of Eye on Spain, its servants or agents.


1 | 2 | 3 |
Our Weekly Email Digest
Name:  
Email:
   


This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse you are agreeing to our use of cookies. More information here. x