Can they really do this?

Post reply   Start new thread
:: New - Old :: Old - New

Pages: 1 |

Forum home :: Latest threads :: Search forums
The Comments
05 Jun 2019 21:58 by musicdonna Star rating in Near Huercal-Overa, .... 250 posts Send private message

We have a rental property.  Our tenant, whose tenancy agreement comes to an end at the end of this month, has expressed a desire to buy our property rather than continue to rent.  We are happy to sell when the agreement has finished. But... there is a clause in the contract to say that should the tenant wish to buy either during the agreement or after (how long after??), it must go through th eestate agents who set up the agreement.

Is this correct?  They have already been paid to do the work connected with the rental.  Can they really demand a commission after a rental agreement has finished?  Maria de Castro, can you shed any light on this, please.  Thank you.


Donna (site for artists of all levels!)

Like 0      
05 Jun 2019 22:33 by perrypower1 Star rating in Derbyshire/Fuerteven.... 647 posts Send private message

perrypower1´s avatar

Yes.  You signed it as did the tenant so it is binding and very common.  

Like 0      
06 Jun 2019 00:01 by Mrsubby Star rating. 75 posts Send private message

Yes it’s common.

if they have been good enough to manage the property for you they are good enough to sell it for you.

I get your point why should they take commission on something you have technically sold yourself.

did they find you the tenant? If so they found you the buyer.

talk to them about reducing their standard fees, has they haven’t had to do any advertising for you or showing potential buyers around.

unless the fees are written in the contract.


This message was last edited by Mrsubby on 06/06/2019.

Like 0      
06 Jun 2019 01:02 by Roberto Star rating in Torremolinos. 4536 posts Send private message

Roberto´s avatar

If you signed a contract with those terms in it, then it's probably legally binding. But presumably you didn't sign anything with regards to the sale price? So, just add the agent's commission on to whatever price you want. Let the tennant/buyer pay it.



"Get your facts first, then you can distort them as you please"

Mark Twain




Like 1      
06 Jun 2019 14:49 by acer Star rating. 1424 posts Send private message

It's not as simple as some folk have indicated here. 

First off there is EU legislation which protects individuals against unfair contract terms imposed by companies.  Secondly companies invariably lose in court if they try and rely on minor tucked away clauses in a contract which have not been made known to the individual, which in fact represent important aspects.

The other aspect to remember is that any ambiguity in a contract is always interpreted against the party that wrote it.  So have a good read and find a reason it is unclear or open to interpretation and go from there.

You mention that there is no indication of the time period involved for which they can claim a fee.  That seems a blunder on their part - it is unreasonable.  It cannot be applied in say 10 years!  If it went to court the decision might be that the contract was voidable, or it might be that the court/judge would decide a period that was fair.  But it may be a starting point and look for others - it's worth the effort, have a strong black coffee and examine every word carefully.   If not use it to agree a compromise.

Good luck
Acer (trainee barrack-room lawyer)

Don't argue with an idiot, he will drag you down to his level and beat you with experience.

Like 0      

Pages: 1 |

Post reply    Start new thread

Previous Threads

good service in Barcelona! - 0 posts
Gardenwaste - 2 posts
First Time Purchase in Spain - 28 posts
Help with Adsense, Please - 1 posts
Yogurts with Live Cultures - 6 posts
Problems with Bankia in 2019 - 12 posts
TV reception Sucina, Murcia - 5 posts
Parking fees Costa del Sol hospital - 0 posts
Sky Remote Control - 8 posts
Who should be next UK PM? - 372 posts
How much notice does a landlord need to give - 13 posts
Costaluz won cases in 2019 - 2 posts
OAPs dependants allowance - 7 posts
how things have changed over the years.. - 2 posts
CASARES del SOL - Court Case Won - 0 posts
Tax refund Mistake - 25 posts
Are your agents giving your property the best? - 6 posts
Hi everyone - 1 posts
Relationship split but joint owned property - 12 posts
Administrator - 3 posts
Car transport to Spain - 6 posts
Legal house on "suelo no urbanizable" - 10 posts
Driving to spain - 31 posts
What buisness would be good idea. (Legally ) - 2 posts
Power of Attorney - 5 posts

Number of posts in this thread: 5

DISCLAIMER:  All opinions posted on these message boards are the opinion solely of the poster and do not necessarily reflect the opinion of Eye on Spain, its servants or agents.

1 |
Our Weekly Email Digest

This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse you are agreeing to our use of cookies. More information here. x