What You Need To Do If Your Spanish Developer Goes Bust?

Published on 11/17/2009 in Buying Process

Please note that the information provided in this article is of a general interest nature and intended as a basic outline only. It is not intended as any substitute for detailed legal or other professional advice specific to the reader’s circumstances. Nothing contained in this article should be seen or taken as the writer or publisher providing legal or financial advice.

Without any intended insult to the text of the Old Testament, the sub-prime disaster in the US begat market jitters, market jitters begat the collapse of age old financial institutions, the institutional collapse begat the credit crunch and the credit crunch begat the withdrawal of project finance. Sprinkle lightly with a reduction in demand and an over supply and what do you have Spanish property developers falling off the perch, howling about liquidity issues and seeking creditor protection under the Spanish equivalent of Administrative Receivership (as in the UK) or Chapter 11 (in the US).

Construction site SpainIn the last month a company owning most of projects of the Grupo Jale, a major developer on the Costa del Sol, and Grupo Sanchez – equally big on the Costa del Sol - entered into Administrative Receivership and this week we heard that San Jose with projects in Murcia has sought similar protection.

Obviously in an already changed market, awash with fears for the security of hard earned money invested in Spanish property, this is not great news.

But where does this leave the property purchaser?

If you have already completed it is likely that your developer may not have sold his entire stock of properties at your new Urbanisation. This means that the developer will also become your neighbour, a member of your Community of Owners and be as responsible as you for their share – their quota - of community fees.

However, the effect of the appointment of an Administrative Receiver over the assets of the company will mean that your Community’s will be required to deal with the office the Administrative Receiver and no longer with the developer themselves. Any subsequent sales of properties at your Urbanisation will generate cash for the Administrative Receiver’s office. This will be used to pay out secured creditors – including the tax and social security offices – but it will also provide cash flow for the continuance of the company under the creditor protection. This means that the developer’s employees – for example - will continue to be paid whilst the company attempts to trade its way out of trouble.

As a consequence, it is likely to be necessary to call either an Extraordinary General Meeting or an Annual General Meeting in order to protect the Communities position in respect of the unpaid Community Fees. I am told that only after these have been voted upon at the EGM or AGM will it enable the Community to enforce the unpaid fees as a debt against any incoming purchaser and thereby collect the unpaid balance. This may be an unpleasant surprise for the incoming purchaser – who’s Abogado should have advised them on such matters and checked with the Secretary of the Community whether any such fees were outstanding. But the legal position appears to be only once the unpaid fees have been voted upon and passed into the Minutes of the Community that following a purchase will the incoming purchaser be obliged to assume responsibility for the unpaid fees. This should benefit the Community.

Alternatively, another potentially interesting scenario is starting to emerge – and we are seeking detailed legal advice on this point as I write. If like any other owner, the developer fails to pay their share of the community fees; will the remaining members of the community – probably a majority – be able to take legal action to recover the debt against the developer? Further should they be successful in obtaining judgment will the Community of Owners be able to obtain an “embargo” over the property to the extent of the Community Fee debt? As a consequence, will the Community then be able to progress to a “subasta” or auction sale of the defaulting owner’s property to realise the unpaid Community Fees? Will this create an interesting new market of distress stock – whereby willing purchasers can acquire finished property at a knock down price?

We believe that this may be relevant where the developer, as is usual, has established an individual company vehicle to develop and sell a particular development. If they have sought creditor protection for only a member of the group of companies – rather than the individual development company - then the moratorium which prevents creditors taking action against the group member but may not apply to the individual development company. Careful review by an appropriately qualified professional is required as group wide creditor protection may operate to prevent a challenge by the Community of Owners.

What if you have not yet completed your purchase but you have paid over your deposit on signing your Private Purchase Contract (PPC) plus – possibly - several stage payments?

Under the terms of the PPC that you have signed, you will usually be acquiring an option to purchase the property at completion. This is not a property right as such but a debt owed to you by the development company with whom you’ve signed your PPC. As in English law, there are different categories of creditors. These include: “Secured” creditors who have registered charges against the development company’s assets probably by way of mortgages or other loans – often manifested in an up to date Nota Simple of the property - the Spanish state tax and social security offices; “Favoured” creditors such as the company’s own employees and “Unsecured” creditors.

Until completion it is usual that a property purchaser will be an “unsecured” creditor of the developer. This means that your rights in respect of your cash as deposited with the developer will mean that you rank behind the “secured” and “favoured” creditors.

Spain has a developed and legally backed system of Bank Guarantees (Aval Bancario). The Law 57/68 establishes a system of bank guarantees - or insurance policies - to protect the amounts paid by the buyers in case of the developer’s failure to complete the development.  The aim is to ensure that you do not lose your money should the property not be built for some reason. This is usually offered by the main funding bank which has provided the developer with their project finance.

In practice, bank guarantees may not always reach the require level of protection as envisaged by the law. In our experience they need to be studied very closely to ensure that they are valid, up to date and signed by all relevant parties. To give you added comfort, you should seek from your Abogado written assurance that they have hold original versions of up to date – amended to include your deposit funds and any subsequent stage payments - fully signed and original Bank Guarantees from the developer’s banker.

Should you find yourselves in a position where your developer has announced that they are entering into a formal creditor protection arrangement or they have filed for, Administrative Receivership, voluntary liquidation or similar you should consider whether it’s appropriate to give your Abogado instructions to seek to call upon the bank’s Guarantee. Whilst it may be difficult in practice to invoke this guarantee – it will usually require the intervention of your Abogado and possibly formal court proceedings – which may prove costly – it should provide you with long stop protection in the event of the collapse of the developer that results in the property not being constructed or completed.

It is not the intention to overly simplify this process and for one reason or another it is likely that the bank providing the guarantee – given the current financial climate - may seek to delay honouring or even refuse to honour their guarantee - so ensuring that your Bank Guarantee arrangements are at all times in “apple pie” order is very sound advice.

If you developer does not appear to be in financial difficulties we’d recommend that you review your Bank Guarantee arrangements in any event. A difficulty often arises if a date of expiry of the Bank Guarantee is specified on its face. Such a date may be an “in any event” date meaning that the Bank Guarantee will expire whether or not the property is “legally” completed. You should check with your Abogado to ensure whether such a date is stated in your case and he/she should apply to have them renewed before they expire. It is usual that the developer and the bank will need to sign each Guarantee and any extension to it which in our experience may well not happen if the developer and their financier are in dispute over other liquidity issues.

I have been approached by some purchaser’s saying that their Abogados failed to advise them in relation to a Bank Guarantee. There may be one of two scenarios here. Firstly, the Bank Guarantee was issued in the usual way - as is required by the law - but for some reason the Abogado just didn’t give the purchaser a copy. In which case, a note to your Abogado’s office should reveal its whereabouts. Secondly – and of much more concern – is where either the Bank Guarantees has not issued for a variety of reasons. This may include that they were not requested by anyone including the purchaser’s Abogado, were not offered or that they were issued and have now expired. Whichever way fully independent professional advice should be sought as to your available remedies against your advisors and the Administrative Receiver – or similar.

Finally, and this sounds like total stupidity, if your property is pretty much completed – snagging done etc. - but lacks - for example - the final formal licences from the local Town Hall – particularly the License of First Occupation (LIFO) - but – and this is an enormous but – your developer is threatening to file for creditor protection, Administrative Receivership or similar, it may be worth considering – if you are in a position to do it – to complete on your property in any event. For obvious reasons, care and professional advice must be taken if you are considering upon such a strategy – it may well be a massive gamble – e.g. the LFO may never be granted - but the net result of such completion will mean that the property is registered in your name. Instead of a debt owed to you by the developer you will have a property asset with an enforceable title.

Right arrow icon Send to friends   Right arrow icon Printer friendly version    Right arrow icon Submit your own article


redman said:
Monday, January 4, 2010 @ 2:03 PM

This article says that a bank guarantee is 'required by the law', anyone (thousands) who have found themselves in the unfortunate situation will know this is untrue. Also, they should not have an expiry date (see supreme court 2009) if they do it can be ignored.

If Bank Guarantees are law, why are none facing criminal prosecution????

Justin said:
Monday, November 30, 2009 @ 4:40 PM

I think you will find it clearly states that it was written by "Mark Wilkins" and his email address is listed there too.

Wednesday, November 18, 2009 @ 1:56 AM

Not sure about the origins of the author as there is no info available .
About the author = Not available .
domus3sixty no info available on author or his/her expertise in this area perhaps it is just an opinion if so it should be made very clear . At least if we read something in the SUN we know it is the SUN If we read the Times we know it is the Times and we always know who the writer is .This allows us to inform an opinion as to how much credence we are willing to afford an article written in a particular paper or by a particular writer . We can research /google the writer and know a little bit about who they are and where they are coming from .Who wrote this ? We do not know therefore can not research any previous writings or ulterior motivesof a corporate nature . Poor show EOS !!!!!! and unacceptable given the subject matter !!!!

Only registered users can comment on this article. Please Sign In or Register now.

Comment Using Facebook:

Related articles in this category

"Ever Thought of Retiring to Spain?", She Asked

10 Year New Build Property Insurance - Seguro Decenal

2007 – The Outlook for Spanish Property….

4 Ways To Help Your Kids Enjoy Their Spanish Holiday

A Quick Guide to Spain's Autonomous Communities

A Room With A View

Agent Property Sharing Systems Cost You Money

Aparthotels - Touristic Apartment Legal Requirements

Bank Guarantees for Spanish Off Plan Developments

Being a Film Set Extra in Alicante

Bored In Spain? Not The Spanish

Breach of Contract - Off Plan Success Story

Building Defects in New Properties

Bullfighting in Spain - On its Last Legs?

Buy Property Safely In Spain...NOT!

Buying a Property in Spain - 10 Points to Consider

Buying a Property in Spain - The Private Contract

Buying A Property in Spain Just Got Safer - And Much More Affordable!

Cave Houses in Spain - ADSL Included!

Completing a new property purchase

Consumer Law - Abusive Clauses In Your Contract

Costa Brava Holiday Ideas

Currency Exchange from Sterling to Euros

Deadly Secrets And Those Books About Spain

Decreto 218 - What It Is And How It Affects Buying Property In Andalucia

Deposit Contract

Dispelling The Myths Of What Is And Isn’t A Snagging Defect And Some Amusing Responses From Builders

DIY snagging - Some pointers on how to ‘Do-It-Yourself’

Do Not Move to Spain if…..

Documento Informativo Abreviado. Brief Informative Document (DIA)

Don't Blame Spain

Don't Criticise the Junta's Actions, Only the Delay in Implementing Them

Eco-Friendly Holidays

Financial And Currency Overview - 2012

Furnishing your Off-Plan

Getting Planning Permission in Spain

Getting The Best Euro Exchange Rate

Help! I'm Busy But Poor!

How to Choose an Architect in Spain

How To Spot The Timeshare Fraudsters

In Times Of Recession Some Imagination Is Needed - Option To Buy

Is Anyone Still Moving To Spain?

Is Disney Coming to Spain? That'll be No.

Is it Dangerous to Buy Property in Spain?

Is Spanish Residential Construction Showing Signs of Recovery?

Is There More To Spanish Wines Than Just Rioja?

It Is Possible Not To Pay Enough For A Property - According To The Tax Man!

It's a Buyer's Market

It's A Good Time To Start Selling Property in Spain

Licence of First Occupation and Completion

Mallorca Property - The Cost Of Buying Explained

More on Consumer Rights When Buying a Property

Most Commonly Asked Questions on Completions and Snagging Inspections

Must Have Common Spanish Phrases To Spice Up Your Spanish

New Regulations Protecting Spanish Property Buyers

No Money? No Problem!

Off Plan Consumer Rights - Sample Purchase Contract

Paramount Theme Park In Murcia - What You Need To Know

Prices Soften As Mortgage Approvals Fall In Lanzarote

Private Purchase Contract - Resale Property

Problems Found by Residential Surveyors in Spain

Property Management - Who Needs It?

Publicity - Part Of The Contract

Real Problems Buying Property in Spain

Result Of Building Standards Survey

Snagging Horror Stories

Snagging Trends & Analysis

So, you want to sell your off plan?

Spain Top Choice for Second Home Abroad

Spain, a Gone Conclusion

Spanish Property Market Stalls On Exchange Rate Strength

Spanish Property Valuations - Confused?

Stimulating The Spanish Property Market – Please Take Note Mr. Zapatero

Taking Better Pictures of Your Property

Taking The Developer To Court - Jan's Story

The art of a successful Snag

The Beginner's Guide to Snagging

The Death Of The Spanish Estate Agent

The Do's And Don'ts Of Buying A Mobile Home In Spain

The Euro - Looking Back and Looking Forward

The Licensing Process For Off Plan Properties In Spain

The Mystery of Spanish Property Online

The Other Side of the Coin

The Right Groups’ – The Costs of Buying in Spain

The Rights Group’s Guide to Buying a Property in Spain

The Spanish Property Crash – Was This What Was Really Happening?

Time to Complete

Time to Complete? - Part 2

Top 10 Reasons To Buy In Spain

Top 3 Budget Restaurants In Central Madrid

Try Before You Buy

Try Before You Buy - A Change In The Property Market

What to do Before and After You Complete on Your New Property

What You Need To Do If Your Spanish Developer Goes Bust?

What's In Store For Spanish Property In 2011?

Where Are All The Property Bargains In Spain?

Who Is REALLY Looking After Your Interest In Spain?

Why Buy On A Golf Resort?

Why Buy Property On A Resort

Why Choose Interest Only For Your Spanish Mortgage

Why You Need a Website To Market Your Rental Property

Click here for a list of all the articles from our magazine 

Spain insurance services

This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse you are agreeing to our use of cookies. More information here. x