Eye on Spain Spanish property forums   "Make friends with your neighbours in Spain" 26,241 people are already members
Members area: Log in  | Create an account
  Home  |  Search  |  Currency Converter  |  Cheap Car Hire  |  Contact & FAQ
 

 A FREE gift for you...



Spain magazine
Sign up for the newsletter here

Taking The Developer To Court - Jan's Story

El PinetIn December 2003 we went on an inspection visit with a company called Feria who were based in Horsham England. (They are no longer operating).  Sam, their sales representative, met us and we were taken to a build in Villa Martin and shown apartments that replicated those that would be built at El Pinet.

Next we were taken to El Pinet and all that were there were 3/4 bedroom houses. At this stage we were told that it had taken 15 years to get planning permission and this would be a unique build. This looked like the perfect area for our holiday home and from plan we purchased a 2 bedroom apartment.

The following day we were taken to Torrevieja to the San Jose offices to sign contracts and pick colour schemes etc. We paid the builders a deposit and were told within 1 month we had to pay half the price of the property which was 67,000 Euros. This we did, in the meantime a solicitor had read the contract and agreed it was good as it clearly stated that if the builders went over the completion date by 3 months we were entitled to our money back. The property was due to be completed in May 2005.

In July 2005 we had not heard anything, so after numerous e-mails trying to find out what was happening and being informed that Feria had nothing to do with the sale now, we got nowhere.

Eventually San Jose gave us weak explanations as to why the property was delayed for example a wet winter etc.  Not happy with this I continued to contact their legal department and in September 2005 they offered us various options. 

These were:

  • Change property to an apartment in a golf complex
  • Provide an apartment to stay in if we come over to see the progress they were making.
  • Terminate the contract.

We considered these options, however, my husband was diagnosed with skin cancer at this time and needed surgery at East Grinstead Hospital.  This made our minds up for us and our solicitor told them we wanted to terminate the contract….but heard nothing.

In January 2006 our solicitor sent a burofax (recorded postal fax) and the builders ignored it.  A second one was sent and the same thing happened. San Jose legal department said they had to speak to their Sales Director.

However, this did not happen, so we were advised to go to a meeting with all parties.  This we did in July 2006 and duly visited the El Pinet build and discovered the apartment was only partially built and that the builders had downed tools in May 2006. At the meeting we were offered compensation of a furniture pack and told the apartment would be finished September 2006.

 “At last” we thought but when our solicitors wanted the completion date in writing it came back as September 2007.  Luckily we hadn’t signed the new contract accepting the compensation package. Our solicitor advised us to take them to court and we went to London to enable our solicitor to have power of attorney. In May 07 we were instructed by our solicitor that we had to go to Orihuela to appear at court in July 2007.

We had a pre meet with our solicitors who said they had an interpreter for us and that we would be called to the stand one at a time to state our case. This was an anxious day for us having never been to court before.  We eventually got into the court room two hours late only to be told San Jose did not want to speak to us. Our solicitor was angry and told the judge so. The judge listened to both cases, this is where we found out that the builders had had planning permission revoked before we had signed the contract in 2003 but we were never informed of this.  In September we were informed that the judge had found the sentence in our favour and we were awarded all monies back including legal costs and expenses.

San Jose appealed and this could take yet another year of misery.  These builders have no idea of customer care. The contract is not worth the paper it is written on. They are unscrupulous and we want nothing to do with them.

Written by

Jan Don

 

View printer friendly version of this article

Send this article to your friends

Submit your own article


Comment on this article:

You need to be a registered member of Eye on Spain to post a comment about this article.  To register your details and obtain an Eye on Spain user name please click here. Registering is very quick, easy and FREE!.

Username *  Don't have a user name?
Password * 
Your comment * 
Forgotten log in?  Items marked * are required

Comments:

CommentDateUser
Hi Jan, we put a deposit on a property in San Juan de los Terreros that was supposed to start in early 2003 or we got 2 x deposit back.
They hadn't got a license and didn't look like ever starting, but when we told our solicitor to get back what we were due, they said that the developers, refused and it would cost more to take them to court than we would get back.
In July 2003 we put a deposit on a villa on Agua Nueva near Turre, that was to be finished in 24 months . After many delays this finaly got started. 24 months later they still hadn't got the building license that our solicitor had said they had.
Every month since the finish date the villa was only 1 month or 2 weeks away from being finished.It is now 51 months ( 27 months late )and we have demanded our money back plus the 6% interest as Spanis law says we are due.
You guessed it they rarely answer our calls or E-mails and its going to take a lot of time and money to get my 50% stake back.
It doen't seem to matter what the law says, you just try and inforce it. We Britt's, being used to developers and solicitors at home are sitting ducks, and up until recently we were arriving in droves thinking we were dealing with a country with some sort of law and order.
Maybe it's just not our sort of law and order.


10/16/2007 9:03:00 PMGlenys Green
Jan,

I have been trying to get my money back on an offplan that hasn't started and have had enough and intend suing. Looking for a good lawyer....
11/7/2007 1:13:00 PMseanw
Hi Seanw

Did you have any looking with Suing for your deposit back? We have bought with San Jose our property was supposed to be completed in May 2007. We want our deposit back also but not having much luck. Looks like we are going to have to take the to court.

12/3/2007 12:26:00 PMvanessa1
Jan,
Could you please help me; I am in the same situation as yours. Could you please provide me the contact information of your solicitor, as I cannot find a good lawyer. My e-mail address is moscars@hotmail.co.uk. Could you please send me the contact information on this address. I would very much appreciate it. Many thanks.
3/3/2008 8:19:00 PMbestsisters
Hi Jan
I have a court case on the 31st March with the builder cancelling the contract as they ahev delayed the completion. I was quite hopeful until I read your story.
I will let you know of the outcome is.
3/7/2008 12:14:00 PMmadhushah53


Related articles of interest

 
2007 – The Outlook for Spanish Property….
A Room With A View
Agent Property Sharing Systems Cost You Money
Aparthotels - Touristic Apartment Legal Requirements
Bank Guarantees for Spanish Off Plan Developments
Building Defects in New Properties
Buying a Property in Spain - 10 Points to Consider
Buying a Property in Spain - The Private Contract
Cave Houses in Spain - ADSL Included!
Completing a new property purchase
Consumer Law - Abusive Clauses In Your Contract
Currency Exchange from Sterling to Euros
Deposit Contract
DIY snagging - Some pointers on how to ‘Do-It-Yourself’
Documento Informativo Abreviado. Brief Informative Document (DIA)
Don't Blame Spain
Furnishing your Off-Plan
Getting Planning Permission in Spain
Getting The Best Euro Exchange Rate
It's a Buyer's Market
It's A Good Time To Start Selling Property in Spain
Just Why Is Denia In Alicante So Popular?
Licence of First Occupation and Completion
Mallorca Property - The Cost Of Buying Explained
More on Consumer Rights When Buying a Property
Most Commonly Asked Questions on Completions and Snagging Inspections
New Regulations Protecting Spanish Property Buyers
No Money? No Problem!
Off Plan Consumer Rights - Sample Purchase Contract
Private Purchase Contract - Resale Property
Publicity - Part Of The Contract
Real Problems Buying Property in Spain
Snagging Horror Stories
Snagging Trends & Analysis
So, you want to sell your off plan?
Spain Top Choice for Second Home Abroad
Spanish Property Market Stalls On Exchange Rate Strength
Spanish Property Valuations - Confused?
Taking The Developer To Court - Jan's Story
The art of a successful Snag
The Beginner's Guide to Snagging
The Mystery of Spanish Property Online
The Other Side of the Coin
The Right Groups’ – The Costs of Buying in Spain
The Rights Group’s Guide to Buying a Property in Spain
Time to Complete
Time to Complete? - Part 2
Top 10 Reasons To Buy In Spain
What to do Before and After You Complete on Your New Property
Where Are All The Property Bargains In Spain?
Who Is REALLY Looking After Your Interest In Spain?
Why Buy On A Golf Resort?
Why Buy Property On A Resort

Click here for a list of all the articles from our magazine 


A selection of threads from our general forum:

Debonair Air Conditioning
any opinions on Formentera del Segura ?
Constitution day.
mike/karalyn
beverley robinson
Over 200 posts
Inspection Trips advice
Hi
Sterling account?
Members.. see SPI postings re Fibby (& JeansSis) here.


A selection of Spain area guides:

Fleix
Pinos
Yunquera
Berja
El Planet
Campillos
Almerimar
Bogarre
Torremendo
Tercia (Lorca)