All EOS blogs All Spain blogs  Start your own blog Start your own blog 

El blog de Maria

Your daily Spanish Law reporter. Have it with a cafe con leche. www.costaluzlawyers.es

Legal tip 1203. Timeshare out in Spain
Wednesday, September 10, 2014 @ 6:57 AM

Spanish Law on Timeshare . Getting out?

All contracts trading rights to use one or more real estate in Spain during a specific or specifiable period along the year are under this law whatever place and date of contracting.

Time share rights are those which give to the holder the faculties for use and enjoyment of an independent dwelling, with exclusive character, for a specific period of time within the year.. It includes the necessary furniture for this use and the complementary services. It is regulated in Spain by a Law dated 1998 and have been extended by a 2012 Law.

The Spanish regulation considers time-share as a type of seasonal rental. The holder of time-share rights does not acquire ownership rights but the right to use the property for a specific period of time. The duration of these rights is not indefinite; the developers of these type of complexes needs to specify the period for the enjoyment of these rights which will always need to be between 3-50 years. Ownership remains being the developers´.

Because ownership is of developer´s, this can sell ownership rights always with the limitations derived from the existence of other person´s use and enjoyment rights on the sold unit, which will remain for the contracted period.

Provision 1.4 of Law 42/1998 prohibited the denomination of those rights as “multiownership" or any other way containing the word “ownership"  “ owner” or "property".

For this reason, any contract signed in Spain contained the word “ownership or property" (propiedad) is null and void and you have rights to the refund of money paid plus legal interests.

In Spain, the denomination that was finally chosen, as most appropriate, descriptive and loyal to Law is "derecho de aprovechamiento por turno", which means “right to use and enjoyment  in shifts"

Publicity or promotion of these type of developments can never either contain the word "propiedad"(property or ownership)

The timeshare scheme can only be formed on a building, property or set of them which are architecturally individual or separated.  All independent units included in it, with the exception of premises, should be subject to the scheme. The building needs to have, at least 10 units. 

The same building can be subject at times to a different tourist operation, provided that the rights of timeshare accommodations fall on concrete and specific periods and units. 

The annual use/enjoyment period can never be less than 7 continuous days. In every case, within the same scheme, shifts should all have the same length. The units will also be reserved for repairs, cleaning or other common purposes for a period of time which shall not be inferior to seven days for each unit subject to the regime.

Cooling off period is of 14 days. No advanced payment, constitution of guarantee, reservation of money in account or debt acknowledgement in favor of the trader or third party can be made before the end of the withdrawal period

All the pre-contractual info and advertising needs to be provided in advance and through an standard form as per regulations.

Contract needs to be in written and in both consumer and trader language if this last operates in Spain.

Main legal characteristics of time share rights in Spain are:

- It is a limited ownership right (enjoyment): two or more different people hold rights on same property: the owner and the holder/s of enjoyment rights. 

- It is immediate, as, in shifts, it gives to its holder a direct enjoyment of the property.

-It has entrance in the Land Registry which gives to its holder a complete legal safety within the Spanish legal system. Obviously time share rights need to be transmitted by Notary deeds for its entrance into the Land Registry.

-It can be transmitted to others either in life or by death. They are part of the property trade.

 
 

Together with desisting from or cancelling the time share contract, possibilities that are subject to a shorter deadline, there is the possibility, initially sine die (without deadline) to apply for the nullity of the contract.

In what cases?

- When timeshare rights are transmitted disregarding the imperative Law which regulates them.

- When the transmission of time share rights are made before the scheme is actually constituted

- When there is a lack of veracity on information provided to the buyer. 

The action for the refund of amounts linked to the nullity has a 15 years deadline.

There is numerous precedents in Spanish Courts for the nullity and refund of money if you were sold under the term " propiedad"(property)

The important issue of adaptation

From January 1999 any preexisting timeshare regime needs to adapt to this Law. If this has not happened, any holder of timeshare rights will be able to request a Judge to compel the developer to do so.

Adaptation will always require a Notary deed and proper registration in the Land Registry.

Adaptation will respect the nature of rights which were transmitted by virtue of the old private contract. If ownership was transmitted, this is what it will have to be registered after approval of simple majority of Community of owners.

All old contracts will have a time limit of 50 years unless parties have agreed otherwise or parties mutually or freely agree in the adaptation deed on a different definitive or non-definitive period.

If the owner of the development does not comply with the obligation of adapting the regime to this new regulation, the holder of timeshare rights will have rights to cancel the contract with effective devolution of amounts and compensation of damages.

2 recent Court decisions on Timeshare and associated bank loans

Asturias Appeal Court, January 2014

A recent Court Decision by Asturias Appeal Court establishes the nullity of the timeshare contract, applying provision 1261 of the Spanish Civil Code and request not just the Timeshare company but the related Bank ( jointly and severally) to refund the consumer all amounts paid plus legal interests plus legal costs. Under the theory of linked contracts.

Asturias Appeal Court estimates that the Bank acted as exclusive entity for the financing of the product and therefore both contracts are linked and both affected by the nullity vice.

Madrid Appeal Court, February 2014

Madrid Appeal Court estimates the appeal filed by the purchasers of timeshare rights and cancel both the  contract and the associated personal loan under the theory on linking contracts. 

There is a very relevant breach of contract by the seller as the buyer was never informed on his rights of  withdrawal and unilateral cancellation of the contract.

Simancas, Valladolid, North western Madrid, Spain, at facebook.com

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


Like 0




16 Comments


Hephaestus said:
Wednesday, September 10, 2014 @ 11:57 AM

We have owned specific weeks in McDonalds, Dona Lola, in Calahonda since 2002. This year we were asked to vote in respect of relinquishing our property specific rights in favour of a floating points system. We didn't bother voting as it appeared to be a fete de complete as McDonalds held the voting rights of all weeks where the service charges were in arrears.

They have now informed us that we can resign from the floating points system for a fee od £1,750.00 per week, subject to our service charges being paid up to date.

Is this legal, as we bought specific units for specific reasons? We intend to visit next year, subject to them not allocating us with inferior units, we will then be able to talk to other 'owners'. If we decide that the new system is not for us what would be the repercussions of us ceasing to pay the service charges?

Thanks in anticipation.


mariadecastro said:
Wednesday, September 10, 2014 @ 12:16 PM

Dear Crookesey:

Would you mind sending an email to me to:

web @ costaluzlawyers so I can peruse your documents and give opinion on your specific case to you?

Kindest,

María


Hephaestus said:
Wednesday, September 10, 2014 @ 12:39 PM

Maria,

Your email address is invalid.


mariadecastro said:
Wednesday, September 10, 2014 @ 12:42 PM

Apologies. It is as follows:

web/at/costaluzlawyers.es
Or if you prefer let me know yours

Kindest,
María


lily2511 said:
Saturday, September 13, 2014 @ 11:15 AM

There are many, many owners at this particular company's Spanish resorts this has happened to, and are very unhappy as this company has taken the bricks and mortar into their own ownership, and are going to remove some of these properties, and make a big profit from them, and in return, they are issuing points to the owners that have no value, as they can't be transferred or sold, and no guarantee the owners will be able to get their own property and weeks, that cost the owners thousands of pounds or euros, and came with a contract that was notarised. How can this be legal, and would this come under Spanish law, as these contracts were signed in Spain?


Hephaestus said:
Saturday, September 13, 2014 @ 12:37 PM

I think that McDonalds are in trouble, the apartments are mostly empty, the reception area is very lightly staffed and the normally 'Forth Bridge' painting regime appears to have come to a stand stop.

Luckily our two weeks only cost us £1550 plus legals, we recently were recompensed to the tune of £2150 in respect of a week in La Manga Club that cost £450 circa 25 years ago when the club was wound up and the proceeds of the property sa;les apportioned to the members.

As we have paid our current service charges we will go next year and no doubt talk to other members. We are minded to just stop paying the service charges and let them do their worst, bugger them they are as bent as a nine bob note.


ceejayblue said:
Saturday, September 13, 2014 @ 12:48 PM

There is a group on Facebook that are campaigning to get the vote overturned as Macdonalds seemed to be rushing things through and not giving owners the chance to thoroughly investigate their options. If anyone is interested please look for Owners Against Macdonalds Resorts on facebook and ask to join, you will find lots of helpful information and advice there. All they ask is the details of your resort, weeks owned and apt no. and an email address. The details will not be passed to anyone else. Here's a link to the facebook page:

https://www.facebook.com/groups/1458462974433443/


ceejayblue said:
Saturday, September 13, 2014 @ 12:49 PM

Cooksey - you should never put your personal email address on an open forum or group, you are leaving yourself open to getting lots of spam emails.


Hephaestus said:
Saturday, September 13, 2014 @ 1:16 PM

Thanks, did so last week.

Greed has got the better of McDonalds, someone told me last year that the Dona Lola reception guys are known as being very difficult with 'owners'. Last year I gave them my mobile number in respect of us exchanging a week to another apartment, they simply handed it to their re-sales guy, they eventually charged us £128 to do this, this used to be free to 'owners'.

Rental property has improved by leaps and bounds over the last few years, timeshare units are now looking very tired due to lack of expenditure. We can rent a luxury 2 bed, 2 bath right on the Benissa coast for less than we pay in service charges for our 1 bed units, we have been renting a new 4 bed, 3 bath villa with pool for just over the one bed service charges, the days of timeshare is well and truly over.


lily2511 said:
Sunday, September 14, 2014 @ 12:33 PM

Are our contracts with MacDonalds that were signed in Spain, covered by Spanish law, as we have been told they are covered by Scottish law?


Hephaestus said:
Sunday, September 14, 2014 @ 3:38 PM

It doesn't really matter, units or points are worthless, however we bought time in actual units, McDonalds say that we can't have them anymore and must pay 4X the service charges of the units that they have taken off us in order to cancel our 'ownership' obligations.

Can you imagine any court of law in the free world finding against us if we cease paying for something that has been taken from us? They need the 4x payments in order to make back the missing service charges of those who have already thrown in the towel. The McDonalds resorts would make very good package holiday destinations, IMHO this is what it's all about.

McDonalds have habitually creamed off a third of all service charges over the years, they are the masters of their own downfall, stuff them.


ceejayblue said:
Sunday, September 14, 2014 @ 6:33 PM

The facebook group Owners Against Macdondalds has now got its own website. If anyone is a Macdonalds owner and wishes to join please do:

http://www.macdonaldowners.org.uk/


shell20 said:
Sunday, September 14, 2014 @ 8:39 PM

if you want to give up your timeshare weeks or points if you are in a points system you should be able to do so without penalty

if they want 2K plus then this is either illegal or unenforceable

I know several people who have given up their timeshares /They live in the UK have informed the Timeshare company in writing and not paid any more money even areas

They received telephone calls and letters asking for the money
but no action was or could be taken against them and the demands for money eventually stopped

These demands for money are not enforceable but for most people the letters and telephone calls are very unpleasant

otherwise you need to get legal advise
you need to get legal advise




shell20 said:
Sunday, September 14, 2014 @ 8:54 PM

I would recommend Stephen Boyd
Associate at Linder Myers
Timeshare Consumer Assoc
He also wrote a section in a Telegraph article recently
Just Google for Further details


mariadecastro said:
Monday, September 15, 2014 @ 8:48 AM

Crookesey:
You can email eos_team at eyeonspain.com for the removing of your personal email.

Once I see McDonalds documents issued to buyers, I will be able to see the way out. Time share consumers are highly proptected both in Europe and national level.

We have been working close and are recommended by TCA ( Timeshare Consumers Association) in the UK

http://www.timeshareconsumerassociation.org.uk/legal/getting-out-of-a-timeshare/



Hephaestus said:
Monday, September 15, 2014 @ 2:53 PM

The actual mention of 'Timeshare' normally brings out the insults and abuse from folk who have never taken a risk in their lives. I don't know about you guys, but we've had some great times on the back of our timeshare ownership. Our total outlay for three weeks including legals was circa £2,900, and we were paid £2,150 from the wind up and sale of La Manga Club and it's units.

We would have been happy to continue using our McDonalds weeks until this happened, it's all about right and wrong now. If we've continued to pay our expensive service charges and not wrecked the units, what have we done to deserve this shabby treatment?


Only registered users can comment on this blog post. Please Sign In or Register now.




 

This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse you are agreeing to our use of cookies. More information here. x