All EOS blogs All Spain blogs  Start your own blog Start your own blog 

EOS MAIL BOX

This blog will be available for all those who wish to publish a story or a anything of interest related to Spain and don't necessarily want to write a blog. Just forward your article or story to info@eyeonspain.com and we'll publish it for you....if it's interesting of course!

Spanish Senate rejects homeowners bid to improve the reliability of the Land Registry
Friday, May 29, 2015 @ 8:12 PM

Land Registry still not obliged to record existence of planning irregularities or demolition orders
 
Homeowners associations from across Spain failed in their bid to persuade the Spanish Senate to vote in favour of an amendment to the law regulating the Land Registry aimed at protecting buyers who purchase a house with a clean bill of health from a Land Registry Search (Nota Simple) only to find that the property has planning issues or even a demolition order.
 
‘I think that we have lost a great opportunity to provide more legal security to those buying a house in Spain’ said Maura Hillen from  AUAN, one of the two British groups who went to the Senate on 27th May in a last ditch effort to persuade Senators from the majority party, the Partido Popular, to support the amendment. ‘Given that all parties seem to agree on the necessity for this change it is difficult to explain why the change didn’t happen’ she said.
 
The amendment was submitted by the Socialist Senator, Fuensanta Coves from Andalucía, with the backing of her party, the PSOE. It was supported by 63 Senators from the Socialist group in the Senate but was defeated when 149 Senators from the ruling PP party voted against the change.

 


 

 

Gerardo Vazquez, the spokesperson for the second British group, SOHA, said ‘We believe that at least we ensured that these issues are being debated at the highest levels and that the Senate is now aware of the existence of these social issues. As a result we are sure that sooner or later these problems will be resolved. We of course hope that it will be sooner’.
 
Antonio Vilela, from the Spanish association, AMA, added ‘The PP agree that changes are required, but indicated that due to lack of time and other issues it couldn’t be done in this Plenary session. They have invited us to submit our all our proposals so that they can consideration for incorporation with other legislative changes in subsequent Senate Plenaries.’
 
In response to this the associations have declared their intention to submit their initiatives to all political parties next week. In particular they will focus on a proposed change to the Contentious Administrative Law to guarantee prior compensation to purchasers in good faith should their property be demolished via the Administrative Courts.

 

In reference to the proposed change to the Land Registry legislation Mrs. Hillen concluded, ‘We may have lost that particular battle but we plan to move on to the next proposal and will submit our next initiative to all political parties next week. We won’t give up because we have right on our side and we are not asking for the earth, just common sense measures that benefit everyone’.  

 

 

Contact: Maura Hillen -  info@almanzora-au.org



Like 1




7 Comments


midasgold said:
Saturday, May 30, 2015 @ 8:37 AM

Looks to me that it was a PP/POSE clash - nothing to do with the actual proposed bill.


alant said:
Saturday, May 30, 2015 @ 9:57 AM

Could not agree more, Cantoria demolishons a reversal of the party's, Junta de Andalusia ( PSOE.) Alcalde, Cantoria P.P.


barker said:
Saturday, May 30, 2015 @ 10:09 AM

Spain ought to get on and make these changes so folks can buy securely , too much talk not enough action. I bought property 14 years ago sold 2 years ago to upgrade to villa only to find illegal build. Thanks to my solicitor doing a good job only lost a small amount of legal fees. Will not buy again till government sort out matters making it safer to buy.


shakeel said:
Saturday, May 30, 2015 @ 11:22 AM

They will not pass any legislations in Spain that gives consumer the rights. Even if they had passed it it will never get implemented in the spirit of the legislations.

The Governments knows very well that the civil servants are incompetent, ill trained, unprofessional, do not take their responsibility/profession seriously as a result they will never be able to compensate people affected.

Spain is a third world Country irrespective of how they dress it up.


ads said:
Saturday, May 30, 2015 @ 3:06 PM

So sad.
A land registry not fit for purpose only accentuates purchasers fears and does a grave disservice to the credibility of Spain's willingness to recognise property rights and abide by international law.

Has this been brought to the attention of the European Commission and British Govt, currently seeking reform of the EU? If so what response has been provided to date?

Are purchasers rights to compensation under these circumstances not considered part of the rule of law?

According to http://www.echr.coe.int/LibraryDocs/DG2/HRFILES/DG2-EN-HRFILES-11%281998%29.pdf

"No one shall be deprived of his possessions except in the public interest and subject to the conditions provided for by law and by the general principles of international law."

"As far as the conditions provided for by law are concerned, it should be noted that the Court has laid down the following requirements: law presupposes the existence of, and compliance with, domestic regulations which are sufficiently accessible and precise (James judgment, para. 67).
Moreover, the reference is not merely to domestic law, but also to its quality, i.e. its compatibility with the principle of the rule of law. The
European case-law is not restricted to property rights – it draws here on the concept of “law” enshrined in Articles 8, 9, 10 and 11. "

......." the rights of foreigners dispossessed of their property are covered by the general principles of international law."

"The general principles of international law, referred to in the first paragraph of Article 1, normally require prompt, appropriate and effective compensation for all forms of deprivation."

Perhaps Maria and team could clarify?


DJF42 said:
Sunday, May 31, 2015 @ 7:16 PM

Shakeel,
Whilst I agree with most of your comments about civil servants it must be said that you can apply your views to those in the UK and I dare say, most of Europe.
They have lost the concept of their names "civil servant". They are nothing of the sort, only there for there own gain and to do as little as possible for the general public.
As for Spain being a third world country, I hardly think so, look at all the infrastructure and changes achieved since Franco pegged it.
What the problem is would seem to be cultural and would you like it if a Spaniard went to the UK and started demanding cultural there?
The sooner property is not considered an investment the the market will be.



DJF42 said:
Sunday, May 31, 2015 @ 7:20 PM

Missed a couple of words, --"started demanding cultural change there"
--" an investment the better the market will be"


Only registered users can comment on this blog post. Please Sign In or Register now.




 

This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse you are agreeing to our use of cookies. More information here. x